Evaluation of STEM Program for Rural Girls (GEMS)

Project Director: Georgia Hall, Ph.D.
Funded by: McElhattan Foundation, under the sponsorship of Bridge Builders Community Foundations


The National Institute on Out-of-School Time (NIOST), directed by Georgia Hall, Ph.D., evaluated the impact of a STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math) education program for rural girls, and is now helping to expand the program’s connections to math and STEM identity activities, as well as to families. The program, GEMS (Girls Excelling in Math and Science), is an international network of hands-on, activity-based, out-of-school time clubs focused on increasing girls’ curiosity, interest, and persistence in STEM. It is designed especially, but not exclusively, for rural girls.


GEMS hosts 16 clubs in Venango County, Pennsylvania through afterschool, library, and summer programs, and serves more than 250 girls in grades 2-12. In 2020, NIOST completed a research study of two of these GEMS clubs, examining what types of science behaviors participants engaged in most frequently, how actively involved they were in the STEM activities, and their affect while doing the STEM activities.

In 2021, GEMS and NIOST received additional funding to expand connections to math and STEM identity activities for girls participating in GEMS clubs throughout the Venango and Clarion Counties area, with specific focus on Franklin, Oil City, and Knox. Building on the effective practices previously identified, this project will increase the scope and depth of math-focused and STEM identity-focused activities implemented in GEMS clubs, and develop a toolkit for parents so they can be more informed and prepared to best support their daughters’ participation in GEMS clubs.


In its research study of the two GEMS clubs in Venango County, NIOST found that GEMS girls were actively involved in STEM projects in a hands-on way. In club activities, they engaged in a wide range of science behaviors, such as exploring, experimenting, observing, discussing, using tools, and asking questions. They enjoyed the process of creating, innovating, and solving challenges. They were frequently amazed and joyful about what they were discovering. At no time were they observed to be feeling frustrated, upset, or distressed when they encountered a challenge. They were activated by the challenges they confronted and eager to try to solve them and to connect with each other for help when needed. And they were persistent in their activities and faced challenges by working together.

These findings can be used to formulate strategies for keeping STEM learning strong for rural girls and others during their early experiences in informal STEM learning. For example, useful strategies include keeping girls engaged by ensuring activities are hands-on and challenging; encouraging them to work together; and helping them make connections between what they are doing and what professional scientists do in their jobs, so they start to view themselves as scientists-in-training.

Read more about the results of the study and its implications for effective practices.

Tags: ,


    "NIOST has been an anchor for numerous school age care projects we do, including ASQ (After-School Quality) and Links to Learning. They are a nationally respected organization that Pennsylvania has partnered with for over 20 years."

    – Betsy O. Saatman, TA Specialist/SAC Initiatives, Pennsylvania Key

    "NIOST was a core partner in supporting the development of quality improvement systems across the nine cities that participated in The Wallace Foundation Next Generation Afterschool System-Building Initiative. The NIOST team worked well with other technical assistance partners in the initiative, always willing to pitch in and collaborate with others to make our professional learning community meetings a team effort. I truly hope the Foundation has an opportunity to partner with them in the future."

    – Priscilla M. Little, Initiative Manager, The Wallace Foundation


    "NIOST has been a leader in the out-of-school time field for as long as I can remember, and I have relied on their research, tools, and advice to improve my practice throughout my career. Their staff members are good partners and good listeners, and their influence across the country is palpable."

    – Jane Quinn, Vice President and Director of National Center for Community Schools, Children's Aid Society

    "Georgia Hall, Ellen Gannett, and the NIOST team have been instrumental in driving the healthy afterschool movement. Their dedication to quality practice, informed policy, and collective impact is instrumental in our effort to create healthier communities."

    – Daniel W. Hatcher, Director, Community Partnerships, Alliance for a Healthier Generation

niost logo white

The National Institute on Out-of-School Time

A program of the Wellesley Centers for Women at Wellesley College

Wellesley Centers for Women
Wellesley College
106 Central Street
Wellesley, MA 02481-8203 USA

Directions to NIOST

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. By continuing to use our site, or clicking "Continue", you are agreeing to our privacy policy.
Continue Privacy Policy